Easy Cookie Butter Magic Shell

The only thing better than butter, is a butter that is made with cookies.

I’m a Cookie Butter addict.

This post is dedicated to my lovely friend Kirsten, who shares the same emotional connection with Cookie Butter that I do. 

If you haven’t tried this stuff then boy do I feel sorry for you! My friend works at Trader Joe’s (where they sell it) and says that they have to limit people on how many jars they can buy at one time because people will go and sell it on the internet (because that’s normal?).

If I’m not just eating this delicious nectar of the gods out of the jar with a spoon, then I’m making Cookie Butter Magic Shell and pouring it all over my ice cream.

It literally takes 30 seconds to make, and it is a total game (dare I say life?)- changer.

Go play!

Easy Cookie Butter Magic Shell


*makes enough for two bowls of ice cream

  • 1 tsp virgin coconut oil
  • 1 Tbsp Trader Joe’s Speculoos Cookie Butter (creamy, not chunky)


  1. In a small bowl, add coconut oil and cookie butter.
  2. Microwave for 10-20 seconds depending on the strength of your microwave, or until melted (it doesn’t take long at all)
  3. Pour over ice cream and let sit 30 seconds or until hardened!

Easy Cookie Butter Magic Shell

Easy Cookie Butter Magic Shell